miLearning

A generation missing out: 15 years of measuring inactivity. Is it time to measure what matters?

Written by Greg Dryer | Nov 19, 2026, 8:03:13 PM

The World Health Organization's latest report, A generation missing out, paints a familiar and deeply concerning picture of adolescent physical inactivity.

The headline findings are stark:

  • 86% of adolescents aged 11–17 do not achieve 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity on all seven days of the week.
  • 25% reported not reaching 60 minutes on a single day during the previous week.
  • Young people averaged just 2.7 days per week reaching that threshold.
  • Girls remain significantly less active than boys.
  • There has been virtually no progress since 2010.

The report draws on surveys involving more than three million young people across 140 countries and territories. It represents an enormous research effort and provides valuable evidence of persistent inequalities.

But there is something troubling about these findings beyond the numbers themselves. We have been having essentially the same conversation for decades. We measure inactivity. We express alarm. We highlight the health consequences. We call for urgent action. And then, 10 or 15 years later, we repeat the exercise.

Surely it is time to question whether we are asking the right questions.

Movement is a human experience, not simply a health intervention

Much of the global physical activity conversation is framed through a biomedical lens. Physical activity is something we must do to prevent disease, manage weight, improve cardiovascular fitness and reduce future healthcare costs.

These benefits are real and important.

But this framing risks treating the human body as a functional machine rather than part of a whole person with feelings, relationships, aspirations, anxieties and a need for connection.

Movement is something we experience.

We experience joy, excitement, frustration, embarrassment, confidence, belonging and exclusion. We develop relationships with other people, with activities, with places and, importantly, with ourselves. These experiences shape whether we want to be active again tomorrow, next week or in 20 years' time.

Yet none of this is captured by asking young people how many days in the previous week they accumulated 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity.

That question tells us something important. But it leaves an enormous amount unexplored.

Is 60 minutes, seven days a week, really the measure of success?

The WHO recommends that young people accumulate an average of at least 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity per day across the week.

There is substantial evidence supporting the health benefits of regular activity. But the precise threshold is not a magical boundary between healthy and unhealthy. Indeed, the WHO itself recognises that some physical activity is better than none.

Yet the headline statistic of 86% insufficiently active is based on the proportion of young people who did not report reaching 60 minutes on all seven days.

Consider two young people.

One participates in three wonderful activity sessions each week. They feel competent, connected and valued. They have fun, make friends and look forward to returning.

The other participates every day but finds the experiences miserable. They feel judged, excluded or inadequate. Activity becomes something to endure rather than enjoy.

Under a purely frequency-based measure, the second young person appears more successful. But which is more likely to develop a positive, sustainable relationship with physical activity? Which is more likely to remain active into adulthood? We cannot answer these questions from activity frequency alone.

More activity is not automatically synonymous with a better experience. And meeting a numerical target is not the same as developing a healthy relationship with movement.

We should be interested in both.

The most important statistic might be the 25%

For me, the most significant finding is not the 86%. It is the quarter of young people who reported not reaching 60 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous activity on any day of the previous week. To be clear, this does not mean they did no physical activity whatsoever. But it raises important questions.

  • Why are these young people less active?
  • Have they had negative experiences of PE or sport?
  • Do they feel competent and confident?
  • Are they welcome in the activities available to them?
  • Do they feel safe? Can they afford to participate? Do they have friends to participate with?
  • Have they simply not discovered an activity that interests, excites or inspires them?
  • And, perhaps most importantly, what would need to change for them to want to participate?

We cannot answer these questions by counting minutes. We need to listen to young people.

Quality of experience is not an optional extra

Sport, physical activity and meaningful movement can be life-enhancing and life-prolonging. But if we want young people to develop enduring relationships with activity, the quality of their experiences matters enormously. Positive experiences can foster confidence, competence, autonomy, connection and belonging. Negative experiences can do the opposite.

A young person who repeatedly feels embarrassed, marginalised or unsuccessful may learn that physical activity simply isn't for them. And that lesson can stay with them for years.

This is why we should be wary of approaches that prioritise participation numbers without paying equal attention to what happens during participation. Getting a young person through the door is important. What happens when they get there may determine whether they ever come back.

There is also a fundamental distinction between compliance and commitment. A young person can comply with an instruction to be active without developing any desire to be active independently. Surely our ambition should extend beyond getting young people to complete prescribed amounts of activity.

We should be helping them discover activities they value, understand themselves as movers, make informed choices and develop the confidence and motivation to remain active throughout their lives. This has profound implications for how we teach PE, organise sport, design programmes and evaluate their success.

From monitoring inactivity to supporting participation

The WHO's work is valuable in establishing the scale of the challenge. And the organisation rightly recognises the importance of safe, accessible and enjoyable opportunities.

But we need to translate those principles into practical action. Rather than simply asking whether young people are sufficiently active, we should also be asking:

  • What are they doing, both in and out of school?
  • What do they enjoy, and what do they avoid?
  • How do different activities make them feel?
  • Are they developing confidence, competence and a sense of belonging?
  • How are their interests and experiences changing over time?
  • What can teachers, coaches and organisations do differently in response?

This isn't about abandoning quantitative measures. It's about making them more meaningful by combining them with young people's experiences and perspectives. And critically, it's about connecting monitoring and evaluation with the everyday work of supporting young people.

The miMove perspective

At miMove, our work is built around a simple belief.

Every young person deserves the opportunity to develop a healthy, positive and lasting relationship with physical activity.

That relationship cannot be measured by minutes alone. It develops through experiences, reflection, choice, confidence, connection and belonging.

This is why we believe young people's voices and experiences must be central to how we understand participation and evaluate our efforts.

We need to know not simply who is participating, but what the participation is like, what it means to young people and how they influence future choices.

If a young person is disengaging, we should want to understand why. If an activity consistently generates positive experiences, we should want to understand what makes it successful. If particular groups are missing out, we should identify and address the barriers.

And if young people are discovering activities they love, we should do everything possible to nurture those relationships.

Because success is not simply a young person achieving a prescribed number of minutes for one week.

Success is a young person developing a relationship with movement that enriches their life and that they want to sustain.

What will the next report tell us?

After 15 years of virtually no progress, surely we must be willing to challenge some of the assumptions underpinning our approaches.

We need to focus not only on increasing opportunities but on improving their quality.

And we need to connect monitoring and evaluation with practical, responsive support.

Otherwise, we risk continuing to measure the same problem without sufficiently changing the conditions that produce it.

The next WHO report might arrive in 2041.

Will it tell us, once again, that nothing has changed?

Or will we finally have started measuring, understanding and nurturing what really matters?

Not simply how much young people move.

But whether they are developing lives that move them.